Skip to main content

Mythodologies: Methods in Medieval Studies, Chaucer, and Book History

  • Joseph A. Dane (author)
punctum books
2018-05-31
Mythodologies: Methods in Medieval Studies, Chaucer, and Book History
Export Metadata
Metadata
TitleMythodologies
SubtitleMethods in Medieval Studies, Chaucer, and Book History
ContributorJoseph A. Dane (author)
DOIhttps://doi.org/10.21983/P3.0202.1.00(opens in new tab)
Landing pagehttps://punctumbooks.com/titles/mythodologies-methods-in-medieval-studies-chaucer-and-book-history/(opens in new tab)
Licensehttps://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/(opens in new tab)
CopyrightDane, Joseph A.
Publisherpunctum books
Publication placeEarth, Milky Way
Published on2018-05-31
ISBN978-1-947447-56-1 (Paperback)
978-1-947447-57-8 (PDF)
Long abstract

Mythodologies challenges the implied methodology in contemporary studies in the humanities. We claim, at times, that we gather facts or what we will call evidence, and from that form hypotheses and conclusions. Of course, we recognize that the sum total of evidence for any argument is beyond comprehension; therefore, we construct, and we claim, preliminary hypotheses, perhaps to organize the chaos of evidence, or perhaps simply to find it; we might then see (we claim) whether that evidence challenges our tentative hypotheses. Ideally, we could work this way. Yet the history of scholarship and our own practices suggest we do nothing of the kind. Rather, we work the way we teach our composition students to write: choose or construct a thesis, then invent the evidence to support it.

This book has three parts, examining such methods and pseudo-methods of invention in medieval studies, bibliography, and editing. Part One, “Noster Chaucer,” looks at examples in Chaucer studies, such as the notion that Chaucer wrote iambic pentameter, and the definition of a canon in Chaucer. “Our” Chaucer has, it seems, little to do with Chaucer himself, and in constructing this entity, Chaucerians are engaged largely in self-validation of their own tradition. Part Two, “Bibliography and Book History,” consists of three studies in the field of bibliography: the recent rise in studies of annotations; the implications of presumably neutral terminology in editing, a case-study in cataloguing. Part Three, “Cacophonies: A Bibliographical Rondo,” is a series of brief studies extending these critiques to other areas in the humanities. It seems not to matter what we talk about: meter, book history, the sex life of bonobos. In all of these discussions, we see the persistence of error, the intractability of uncritical assumptions, and the dominance of authority over evidence.

Print length292 pages
LanguageEnglish (Original)
Dimensions127 x 203 mm | 5" x 8" (Paperback)
LCCN2018941289
THEMA
  • GPS
  • DSBB
  • NHAP
BIC
  • DSBB
BISAC
  • LIT011000
Keywords
  • medieval studies
  • Chaucer
  • book history
  • intellectual history
  • bibliography
Locations
PaperbackLanding page(opens in new tab)
Landing page(opens in new tab)
PDFLanding page(opens in new tab)Full text URL(opens in new tab)THOTH
Landing page(opens in new tab)PROJECT MUSE
Landing page(opens in new tab)Full text URL(opens in new tab)OAPEN
Landing page(opens in new tab)DOAB
Landing page(opens in new tab)JSTOR
Landing page(opens in new tab)Full text URL(opens in new tab)
Landing page(opens in new tab)Full text URL(opens in new tab)INTERNET ARCHIVE
Landing page(opens in new tab)Full text URL(opens in new tab)ZENODO

Contributors

Joseph A. Dane

(author)

Joseph A. Dane is Professor of English at the University of Southern California. His books on book history and bibliography include Blind Impressions: Methods and Mythologies in Book History (Pennsylvania, 2013), Out of Sorts: On Typography and Print Culture (Pennsylvania, 2011), What is a Book? The Study of Early Printed Books (Notre Dame, 2012), and The Myth of Print Culture: Essays on Evidence, Textuality, and Bibliographical Method (Toronto, 2003).